Allen and Arnold Dispute Command at Ticonderoga
# The Dispute at Ticonderoga: Allen, Arnold, and the Battle Over Command
In the spring of 1775, barely weeks after the first shots of the American Revolution rang out at Lexington and Concord, a small but strategically vital British outpost on the southern shore of Lake Champlain became the focus of patriot ambitions. Fort Ticonderoga, situated in the wilderness of northeastern New York, was lightly garrisoned and poorly maintained, but it held something the fledgling American cause desperately needed: cannons, mortars, and military stores that could tip the balance in the growing conflict with Britain. The effort to seize the fort would prove successful, but it was nearly derailed not by British resistance but by a fierce and deeply personal dispute over command between two ambitious men — Ethan Allen and Benedict Arnold — whose clash at Ticonderoga would echo through the rest of the war and beyond.
Ethan Allen was a towering, boisterous figure from the contested region known as the New Hampshire Grants, the territory that would eventually become Vermont. He commanded the Green Mountain Boys, a rough militia originally organized to resist New York's jurisdictional claims over the Grants. Allen and his men were frontiersmen, fiercely independent and loyal to Allen personally rather than to any formal military hierarchy. When word of the fighting at Lexington reached the region, Allen and a small group of Connecticut patriots, including militia officer Captain Edward Mott and civilian organizer Heman Allen, Ethan's brother, began planning a raid on Ticonderoga. The Green Mountain Boys were the natural force for the job — they knew the terrain, they were already organized, and they were eager for a fight. Allen threw himself into the effort with characteristic energy, rallying his men and coordinating logistics for the march north.
Benedict Arnold, meanwhile, had arrived at the same idea independently. A prosperous New Haven merchant and militia captain with sharp military instincts, Arnold had recognized Ticonderoga's strategic value and traveled to Cambridge, Massachusetts, to pitch the plan to the Massachusetts Committee of Safety. Impressed by his confidence and reasoning, the Committee granted Arnold a colonel's commission and authorized him to raise a force of up to four hundred men to capture the fort. Armed with this official mandate, Arnold rode hard for Lake Champlain, expecting to take command of whatever forces had assembled.
When Arnold arrived at the staging area near Hand's Cove on the eastern shore of the lake, he found Allen and roughly two hundred Green Mountain Boys already prepared to cross. Arnold immediately presented his commission and demanded command of the operation. The Green Mountain Boys, however, flatly refused to serve under anyone but Allen. They were volunteers, not regular soldiers, and their loyalty was personal. Arnold, for his part, would not accept a subordinate role when he held the only legitimate military commission on the field. The resulting standoff was bitter and intense, with both men unwilling to back down. Allen had the men; Arnold had the paperwork. Neither advantage was decisive.
The compromise they reached was awkward and telling. On the predawn morning of May 10, 1775, Allen and Arnold entered Fort Ticonderoga side by side, neither formally commanding the other. The small British garrison, caught completely off guard under the command of Captain William Delaplace, surrendered without a significant fight. Allen reportedly demanded the fort's surrender "in the name of the great Jehovah and the Continental Congress," though the exact words have been debated by historians ever since.
The capture of Ticonderoga was a significant early victory for the patriot cause. The cannons and military supplies seized from the fort would later be transported to Boston under the direction of Colonel Henry Knox, where they played a crucial role in forcing the British evacuation of the city in March 1776. Strategically, controlling Ticonderoga and Lake Champlain gave the Americans a critical buffer against a British invasion from Canada.
Yet the personal consequences of the command dispute lingered far longer than the tactical ones. For Allen, the capture of Ticonderoga cemented his reputation as a bold frontier hero, a legend he cultivated for the rest of his life. For Arnold, the experience at Ticonderoga became one of the first in a long series of perceived slights over rank, credit, and recognition. Though Arnold would go on to demonstrate extraordinary bravery and tactical brilliance at battles such as Valcour Island and Saratoga, his chronic sense of being undervalued and overlooked by Congress and fellow officers festered into a grievance that ultimately led him down the path to treason. His 1780 conspiracy to surrender West Point to the British remains one of the most infamous betrayals in American history. The seeds of that betrayal, historians have argued, were planted in moments precisely like the one at Ticonderoga — moments when Arnold's ambition collided with the messy, decentralized realities of the revolutionary movement and left him feeling cheated of the glory he believed he deserved.
2 people